At Clear Cut Gutters, owned and operated by The Gutter Brothers right here in Pittsburg, KS, we know how crucial reliable gutter protection is for your home. With so many options on the market, homeowners often ask us about the difference between two of the biggest names in the industry: LeafFilter and LeafGuard. If you’re searching for “leaf filter vs. leaf guard,” this guide will help you decide on your property.
How Do LeafFilter and LeafGuard Work?
LeafFilter
LeafFilter uses a micro-mesh screen made of surgical-grade stainless steel, installed over your existing gutters. This fine mesh allows water to flow through but blocks even tiny debris like pine needles and shingle grit. The system is supported by a durable uPVC frame and secured with steel hangers to your fascia board, making it a robust solution for homes with good existing gutters.
LeafGuard
LeafGuard is a one-piece, all-in-one gutter and guard system. It uses a patented reverse-curve aluminum design that directs rainwater into the gutter while pushing leaves and larger debris over the edge and onto the ground. LeafGuard requires a full gutter replacement, custom-fitted to your home, and is reinforced with hidden hangers and a scratch-resistant coating.
Key Differences
Type and Installation:
LeafFilter is a micro-mesh guard that installs over your existing gutters, while LeafGuard is a full gutter replacement system with an integrated guard.
Material:
LeafFilter uses stainless steel mesh and a uPVC frame, great for filtering fine debris. LeafGuard is made from thick aluminum with a durable, scratch-resistant finish.
Debris Protection:
LeafFilter excels at blocking small debris like pine needles and shingle grit. LeafGuard is better suited for large debris such as leaves and twigs.
Cost:
LeafFilter tends to be more affordable since it installs over existing gutters, whereas LeafGuard involves replacing your gutters and generally costs more upfront.
Warranty:
Both systems offer strong warranties, including clog-free guarantees, but LeafGuard’s warranty often covers the entire gutter system and coating for a lifetime.
Pros and Cons
LeafFilter Pros:
-
Installs on existing gutters (no need for total replacement)
-
Superior at filtering small debris and pine needles
-
Less visually bulky, blends with roofline
-
More budget-friendly
LeafFilter Cons:
-
Not suitable if your gutters are already damaged
-
May require occasional cleaning if overwhelmed by debris
LeafGuard Pros:
-
Complete gutter and guard replacement, ideal for old or damaged gutters
-
Reverse-curve design sheds large debris efficiently
-
Minimal maintenance required for large leaves and twigs
-
Durable aluminum construction with scratch-resistant finish
LeafGuard Cons:
-
Higher upfront cost due to full system replacement
-
Less effective at blocking fine debris like pine needles
-
Potential overflow issues on very steep roofs
Which Should You Choose?
Choose LeafFilter if: Your existing gutters are in good shape, you deal mostly with small debris, want a less noticeable guard, and prefer a more affordable option.
Choose LeafGuard if: Your gutters are worn out and need replacing, large debris is your main problem, you want a low-maintenance all-in-one system, and you’re ready to invest more upfront.
Clear Cut Gutters: Your Local Gutter Experts
Every home in Pittsburg, KS is unique, and so are its gutter needs. At Clear Cut Gutters, The Gutter Brothers are happy to assess your property and recommend the best solution, whether it’s a high-performance micro-mesh system like LeafFilter, a seamless replacement like LeafGuard, or another custom approach.